网易首页 > 网易号 > 正文 申请入驻

北京烤鸭和广东烧鹅吵了几十年,其实哪个好吃这话一开始就问错了

0
分享至

烤鸭党和烧鹅党,吵了不是一年两年。

一个说:烧鹅那层皮咬下去嘎吱响,肉汁能飙出来,烤鸭净是皮没肉味。一个回:薄饼卷皮蘸甜面酱,那是国宴的排场,烧鹅油得慌。



两边说的都在理。可这场架吵歪了——他们各自拿最得意的那口,去撞对方最得意的那口,谁也不服谁,太正常了。



翻翻两家的老底

烤鸭的祖上是南京烤鸭。明成祖朱棣迁都北京,顺手把烤鸭高手也带了过去,慢慢就成了宫廷菜。北京城那两家老字号也都是硬角色:便宜坊的焖炉,明永乐十四年就开张,六百多年,讲究"鸭子不见明火",全靠炉壁的余热一点点把鸭子焖熟;全聚德的挂炉,清同治三年杨全仁创立,果木明火烤,皮酥肉嫩。2008年,这两门手艺一块儿进了国家级非遗名录。



烧鹅的底子也不薄。岭南传下来的老味道,鹅要挑清远乌鬃鹅这类骨细肉嫩的,肚子里灌进秘制酱汁,缝严实了再上炉。打气、烫皮、风干、刷酱、挂炉,一步都省不得。



拆开那层脆皮,路子差远了

真正的分岔,在火上,也在这口吃食的主次上。

烤鸭那层皮,是慢慢"养"出来的。北京填鸭养到六七斤,脂肪厚,皮也厚。充气把皮和肉撑开,再烫皮、挂糖、风干,最后进炉子。挂炉用枣木梨木的明火,焖炉不见火、靠余温,两条路子殊途同归,要的都是那张薄如纸、入口就化的皮。



所以吃烤鸭有一整套规矩:片鸭师傅一刀一刀片下来,荷叶饼抹上甜面酱,搁几根葱丝黄瓜条,卷起来一口塞进嘴。皮的酥、酱的甜、葱的葱,一层层叠着来。卷饼的时候专挑皮、肉反倒不要的人,我见过不少。烤鸭的主角是皮。



烧鹅走的是另一条道。它用明火"烧",荔枝木的果香在高温里渗进鹅皮那些细密的小孔,鹅油被逼出来,皮脆得能反光,里头的肉汁却给死死锁住了。斩件端上桌,一碟酸梅酱就够。你吃的是皮脆、肉嫩、汁水足,一口下去油香混着酸甜,连骨头都透着味。烧鹅的主角是肉和汁,那层皮是给肉服务的。



一个把皮做到极致,一个把肉和汁做到极致。这才是它们真正的差别,跟哪个更香没关系。

看这顿饭图什么,就有答案了

请客、带外地朋友、想吃顿有排面的,选烤鸭。片鸭卷饼那套动作往桌上一摆,面子就立住了。1972年尼克松访华,广为流传的说法是周总理拿烤鸭招待的,这份排场是它的看家本事。



自己解馋、想踏踏实实吃口肉、最好还能下饭的,选烧鹅。斩半只,配酸梅酱,鹅油往米饭上一浇,一个人抱着鹅腿啃也痛快。老广清明拜山都少不了它,那是自家人吃的味道。



蘸料其实也把性格写明白了:烤鸭配甜面酱,甜里带咸,讲究个圆融;烧鹅配酸梅酱,酸得直接,就是要解那份油腻。一个讲礼,一个重情。一个端上宴席,一个蹲在档口。http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/549957.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/521504.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/920151.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/727262.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/141833.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/388850.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/766874.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/641047.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/205416.shtml
http://wap.365kz.cn/detail/678838.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/662389.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/850174.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/939427.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/608098.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/424877.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/261047.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/449029.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/161304.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/846189.shtml
http://h5.365kz.cn/detail/262958.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/615515.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/746377.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/419271.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/914526.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/545464.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/404497.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/576180.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/783594.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/745385.shtml
http://3g.365kz.cn/detail/980681.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/866428.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/756666.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/476934.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/948844.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/114719.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/505157.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/532479.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/969932.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/310300.shtml
http://wap.365youlian.com/detail/387901.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/389410.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/766143.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/727532.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/609982.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/140185.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/559440.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/560492.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/847896.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/972479.shtml
http://h5.365youlian.com/detail/523762.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/870926.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/373295.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/910115.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/891246.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/340865.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/588752.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/410041.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/634972.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/342370.shtml
http://3g.365youlian.com/detail/778385.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/589131.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/581173.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/142393.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/978388.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/697699.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/693605.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/460767.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/168917.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/514432.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.cn/detail/313304.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/123276.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/584489.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/336687.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/488292.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/146608.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/683868.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/820832.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/963705.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/872776.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.cn/detail/827896.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/232794.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/882980.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/158993.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/341924.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/911915.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/430973.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/236075.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/684781.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/778170.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.cn/detail/860793.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/157676.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/854700.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/915472.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/617523.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/790767.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/691399.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/731445.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/498277.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/807469.shtml
http://wap.4008812356.com/detail/458646.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/984201.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/127683.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/549481.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/628065.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/163550.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/849212.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/771135.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/282051.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/184317.shtml
http://h5.4008812356.com/detail/691859.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/411163.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/547421.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/738961.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/626963.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/539802.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/155028.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/682781.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/969995.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/708946.shtml
http://3g.4008812356.com/detail/310826.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/461734.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/378986.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/691178.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/753501.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/622402.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/333659.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/366405.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/278780.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/767611.shtml
http://wap.5174.com.cn/detail/835029.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/688396.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/320508.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/772723.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/464270.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/208069.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/677195.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/823154.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/507456.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/350395.shtml
http://h5.5174.com.cn/detail/555765.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/945799.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/569170.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/324786.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/678425.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/147439.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/814745.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/373698.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/706178.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/423761.shtml
http://3g.5174.com.cn/detail/128669.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/161505.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/230685.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/459039.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/428735.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/964790.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/188015.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/660405.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/976936.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/992842.shtml
http://wap.51tek.com/detail/228068.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/503543.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/390542.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/926204.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/292408.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/925319.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/150529.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/952549.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/259984.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/221570.shtml
http://h5.51tek.com/detail/145241.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/516983.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/678194.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/622694.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/542232.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/684947.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/657179.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/390693.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/956532.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/471256.shtml
http://3g.51tek.com/detail/877002.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/630066.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/681876.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/900904.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/364020.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/973352.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/281094.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/621163.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/705315.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/789251.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.cn/detail/227480.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/247472.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/161395.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/685597.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/864451.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/993563.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/636993.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/254590.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/618442.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/577430.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.cn/detail/593812.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/424173.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/897908.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/907652.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/423796.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/616278.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/931877.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/611701.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/828091.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/585648.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.cn/detail/364966.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/376316.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/763453.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/491517.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/491940.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/430636.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/712713.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/330459.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/992600.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/233616.shtml
http://wap.51yidao.net/detail/863240.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/350998.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/484206.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/135365.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/887341.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/174160.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/801748.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/973228.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/866637.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/814393.shtml
http://h5.51yidao.net/detail/453277.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/388760.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/623237.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/429882.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/329499.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/572851.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/726678.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/703543.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/495105.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/358530.shtml
http://3g.51yidao.net/detail/856625.shtml



所以别再问哪个更好吃了。先问自己一句:这顿饭,是请人,还是犒劳自己?想明白了,选哪个都不会错。



你家宴客,桌上摆的是烤鸭还是烧鹅?你是卷饼吃皮派,还是斩件啃肉派?评论区报个城市,看看南北两派哪边人多。

特别声明:以上内容(如有图片或视频亦包括在内)为自媒体平台“网易号”用户上传并发布,本平台仅提供信息存储服务。

Notice: The content above (including the pictures and videos if any) is uploaded and posted by a user of NetEase Hao, which is a social media platform and only provides information storage services.

相关推荐
热点推荐
陆毅说:“如果我女儿的男朋友很上进,但家境一般,我会棒打鸳鸯。因为我觉得门当户对很重要,而且婚姻要得到双方父母祝福,才会幸福”!

陆毅说:“如果我女儿的男朋友很上进,但家境一般,我会棒打鸳鸯。因为我觉得门当户对很重要,而且婚姻要得到双方父母祝福,才会幸福”!

财经要参
2026-11-22 23:23:41
局势反转,美国突然反水,宣布对乌新立场,欧盟:这一天终究来了

局势反转,美国突然反水,宣布对乌新立场,欧盟:这一天终究来了

浯江孤舟
2026-11-20 15:18:35
香港金牛太强了!连胜吉林+广东+广州晋级八强,还签约王俊杰补强

香港金牛太强了!连胜吉林+广东+广州晋级八强,还签约王俊杰补强

林小湜体育频道
2026-11-22 22:45:04
扛不住了!网传南昌一民办高校解除劳动补偿协议曝光,大量老师面临失业,网友:民办高校本质就是企业

扛不住了!网传南昌一民办高校解除劳动补偿协议曝光,大量老师面临失业,网友:民办高校本质就是企业

火山詩话
2026-11-22 21:26:43
毛主席最初不想定都北京,到底是谁促使他下定决心的?

毛主席最初不想定都北京,到底是谁促使他下定决心的?

雍亲王府
2026-11-22 08:50:12
连遭三轮袭击,克里米亚大桥已很难修复,俄军开始疯狂报复

连遭三轮袭击,克里米亚大桥已很难修复,俄军开始疯狂报复

兵国大事
2026-11-20 16:37:56
从别人身上偷学到受益终生的好习惯!网友:我等这个帖子等了30年

从别人身上偷学到受益终生的好习惯!网友:我等这个帖子等了30年

另子维爱读史
2026-11-17 17:38:36
特别恶心让人三观尽毁的事你遇见过吗?看完网友分享,眼珠都瞪圆了

特别恶心让人三观尽毁的事你遇见过吗?看完网友分享,眼珠都瞪圆了

另子维爱读史
2026-11-22 21:28:11
从场均7.5分到压哨绝杀,布里奇斯一夜翻身?

从场均7.5分到压哨绝杀,布里奇斯一夜翻身?

篮坛第一线
2026-11-22 23:30:12
国际篮联宣布最新决定,中国男篮收重大喜讯,郭士强运气太好了

国际篮联宣布最新决定,中国男篮收重大喜讯,郭士强运气太好了

宗介说体育
2026-11-22 11:11:52
心梗发病呈年轻化趋势,胸痛记住两个“120”丨健谈

心梗发病呈年轻化趋势,胸痛记住两个“120”丨健谈

新京报
2026-11-20 08:58:13
IGN:《GTA6》高人气美女很恐怖!杰森躲过一劫

IGN:《GTA6》高人气美女很恐怖!杰森躲过一劫

游民星空
2026-11-20 12:11:29
为啥有时候大便之前的体重和大便之后的体重一样?难道排泄物没重量吗?

为啥有时候大便之前的体重和大便之后的体重一样?难道排泄物没重量吗?

向航说
2026-11-20 22:10:04
许绍洋现身成都玉林路,出道25年难被记住,50岁还在走反差这条路

许绍洋现身成都玉林路,出道25年难被记住,50岁还在走反差这条路

Mz娱乐前沿
2026-11-22 20:39:55
张婉婷自曝女儿每月教育花费至少两三万:其中在郎朗那学钢琴45分钟近千元

张婉婷自曝女儿每月教育花费至少两三万:其中在郎朗那学钢琴45分钟近千元

韩小娱
2026-11-22 15:10:00
希拉里公开炮轰特朗普,指责美总统"助纣为虐",呼吁国会展开调查

希拉里公开炮轰特朗普,指责美总统"助纣为虐",呼吁国会展开调查

金戈远望
2026-11-22 23:25:03
收官你请回金晨,属实恶心到我了

收官你请回金晨,属实恶心到我了

喜欢历史的阿繁
2026-11-21 15:01:01
奉劝所有人,一定要少吃,少吃,少吃,千万别不吃!

奉劝所有人,一定要少吃,少吃,少吃,千万别不吃!

荷兰豆爱健康
2026-11-22 00:06:23
墨总统:墨西哥不打算与中国签署自贸协定

墨总统:墨西哥不打算与中国签署自贸协定

俄罗斯卫星通讯社
2026-11-21 16:09:51
高市制造了“舷梯门”

高市制造了“舷梯门”

天真无牙
2026-11-21 14:52:51
2026-11-22 23:59:00
证券时报 incentive-icons
证券时报
运营主体:深圳证券时报社有限公司
1000313文章数 239954关注度
往期回顾 全部

头条要闻

俄导弹落入波兰 北约秘书长吕特强硬回应

头条要闻

俄导弹落入波兰 北约秘书长吕特强硬回应

体育要闻

全场挨打1比4溃败 阿隆索已过保质期?

娱乐要闻

杨颖姐弟烧香被偶遇,清秀少年变粗犷大叔

财经要闻

沪深交易所、中国结算推出一揽子降费措施

科技要闻

Anthropic收涨17.1%,市值一度破2万亿美元

汽车要闻

插混尊贵型真的超值 15万级的第二代海豹07配置拉满

态度原创

艺术
健康
家居
手机
数码

艺术要闻

拉美为何盛产选美冠军:五百年混血底色与一条选美流水线

医生眼里"很伤腰"的椅子,很多人天天坐

家居要闻

2026建博会(广州) 公装联探展交流活动

手机要闻

华为Mate70 Air线下上手:体验后,感觉Mate90 Air提升有限!

数码要闻

消费电子内卷下的封装破局:板级封装为音频芯片按下小型化加速键

无障碍浏览 进入关怀版